Hidden Gem Restaurants in Capri: Where Locals Eat and Travelers Feel Like Insiders
Capri is famous for glamour, yachts, and iconic restaurants overlooking the Faraglioni. But beyond the well known terraces and celebrity hotspots, there is another side of the island. One that rewards curious travelers who step off the main piazzetta paths and follow locals into quieter corners.
This guide focuses on hidden gem restaurants in Capri that deliver authenticity, unforgettable flavors, and often better value. These are the places boat captains recommend, hotel concierges whisper about, and repeat visitors return to year after year.
For travelers arriving by sea, especially those booking private boat services, these restaurants pair perfectly with a relaxed island day that feels personal and exclusive.
Why Seek Out Hidden Gem Restaurants in Capri
Capri is small, but its dining scene is layered. While some of the top restaurants in Capri Italy are world class, many visitors never experience the family run trattorias, scenic cliffside lunches, or inland kitchens where tradition still leads the menu.
Hidden gems offer:
Less crowded dining rooms even in peak season
More interaction with owners and staff
Traditional Capri and Campania recipes
Excellent wine lists at fairer prices
Locations that feel discovered, not staged
For boat travelers, these restaurants often align better with flexible schedules and relaxed arrivals from the marina.
Best Hidden Gem Restaurants in Capri
Da Paolino Lemon Trees
Tucked behind stone walls near Marina Grande, Da Paolino feels like dining in a private garden.
Tables sit under centuries old lemon trees
Classic Capri dishes done with elegance
Romantic but still grounded and authentic
It is one of the most photographed restaurants on the island, yet many first time visitors miss it entirely.
Lo Sfizio
If you want to eat where locals eat, Lo Sfizio is essential.
Family run trattoria near Tiberio
Simple interiors, serious food
Fresh pasta, seafood, and seasonal vegetables
This is not a place for views. It is a place for flavor. Many consider it a contender among the top restaurants in Capri Italy for quality alone.
Ristorante Da Tonino
Located inland along a quiet road, Da Tonino is beloved by Capri residents.
Generous portions
Traditional recipes
Excellent grilled meats and seafood
It is especially popular for relaxed dinners after a long day at sea.
La Capannina
One of Capri’s oldest restaurants, often overlooked by visitors rushing to trendier spots.
Elegant but understated
Classic Neapolitan cuisine
Strong wine cellar
A perfect option for travelers seeking refined dining without the scene driven crowds.
Best Lunch in Capri With a View That Still Feels Like a Secret
Finding the best lunch in Capri with a view does not always mean booking the most famous terrace. These lesser known spots combine scenery with serenity.
Il Riccio Restaurant
Near the Blue Grotto and often accessed by boat, Il Riccio offers:
Dramatic seaside views
Elevated seafood focused menu
Calm daytime atmosphere
Ideal after swimming or cruising along the Anacapri coastline.
Da Gelsomina
High above Anacapri, Da Gelsomina delivers countryside charm and sweeping views.
Panoramic terrace overlooking the sea
House made pasta and rabbit dishes
Shuttle service available
This is a slow lunch destination that pairs beautifully with a relaxed island itinerary.
Hidden Gem Restaurants in Capri at a Glance
Below is a simplified comparison table for quick reference.
| Restaurant | Location | Highlight |
|---|---|---|
| Da Paolino | Marina Grande | Dining under lemon trees, romantic and iconic |
| Lo Sfizio | Tiberio | Authentic local flavors, family run |
| Da Tonino | Inland Capri | Traditional Capri dishes, relaxed dinners |
| Il Riccio | Anacapri Coast | Seafood lunch with dramatic seaside view |
How Boat Travel Unlocks Capri’s Best Restaurants
Many of Capri’s most rewarding dining experiences become effortless when you explore the island by sea.
With a Capri Private Boat Tour, travelers can:
Arrive near Marina Grande or Anacapri without ferry stress
Time lunch reservations around swimming and cruising
Access coastal restaurants like Il Riccio with ease
Avoid crowded transport during peak summer hours
Private boat tours allow you to shape the day around food, not the other way around.
Pairing Restaurants With a Smart Capri Itinerary
For U.S. travelers visiting Capri for one day or as part of an Amalfi Coast itinerary, timing matters.
Here is a sample structure many seasoned visitors follow:
| Time | Experience |
|---|---|
| Morning | Private boat cruise around the island |
| Midday | Lunch at Il Riccio or Da Gelsomina |
| Afternoon | Swim stops and Faraglioni photos |
| Evening | Dinner at Da Paolino or Lo Sfizio |
Why These Capri Restaurants Matter for First Time Visitors
Many ranking articles focus only on the most famous names. While those restaurants are excellent, they often represent only one version of Capri.
Hidden gems reveal:
The island’s culinary heritage
The slower pace locals protect
Experiences that feel personal, not transactional
For travelers investing in private boat services, these dining choices complete the feeling of exclusivity and authenticity.
Final Thoughts on Hidden Gem Restaurants in Capri
Capri rewards travelers who look beyond the obvious. Whether you are seeking the best lunch in Capri with a view, exploring alternatives to the most crowded terraces, or simply wanting to eat well after a day at sea, these hidden gem restaurants offer something rare.
They deliver flavor, atmosphere, and connection to the island’s true character.
If you are planning a boat based visit and want help building the perfect Capri day, including dining logistics and timing, reach out through our Contact Page and let local expertise guide the experience.
People also ask
-
Celebrities in Capri often favor Topolino’s Terrace, Da Paolino, and Ristorante Il Riccio. These spots offer privacy, stunning views, and refined Italian cuisine, making them perfect for high-profile guests.
-
Don’t miss a private boat tour around the island, the Blue Grotto, Faraglioni rock formations, a walk through Anacapri, and sampling local Capri cuisine at hidden gem restaurants.
-
La Fontelina is the most iconic and exclusive beach club, renowned for its cliffside location, crystal-clear water access, and Mediterranean seafood.
-
Yes, Da Paolino is worth it for its lemon-tree dining experience, romantic ambiance, and authentic Capri dishes. It offers a truly memorable experience beyond standard tourist restaurants.
-
Yes, reservations are recommended well in advance, especially during peak summer months, as the restaurant is popular with both locals and visitors.
-
Yes, smart casual attire is recommended for breakfast at Topolino’s Terrace, especially during high season when it hosts a mix of tourists and luxury travelers.
WhatsApp
